The Best Ice Cream in Alexandria: Our Top Ten
The heat is on! Cooling down with some delicious ice cream is a classic way to beat the heat. We’ve rounded up the many unique spots for ice cream in Alexandria. From gelato to custard to classic ice cream sundaes, there is truly something for everyone at one of the many places for ice cream in Alexandria.
IN OLD TOWN
110 King Street
A stone’s throw to the Alexandria waterfront, The Creamery offers homemade ice cream, frozen custard, no-sugar-added ice cream, and dairy-free sorbet. If that’s not enough of a selection for you, cookies and cobblers are also baked in the store. The Creamery is also known for fast service, so don’t let its long line deter you.
726 King Street
A trip to Old Town’s newest ice cream shop, Nicecream, feels like you’ve stepped into the middle of a science experiment. The staff uses liquid nitrogen to make your ice cream right in front of you. Nicecream prides itself on using local products for offering the highest quality ice cream possible. Nicecream’s rotating assortment of flavors is fabulous and makes the most of seasonal ingredients (July’s, for example, is Peachy Keen).
Pop’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream
109 King Street
With its old-fashioned atmosphere and fabulous customer service, Pop’s Old Fashioned Ice Cream is a local favorite. You can find the usual standby flavors at Pop’s, but also some truly unique ones like Kahlua Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel, and Carrot Cake. Or try one of their specialty sundaes such as the “Johnny Appleseed,” with vanilla ice cream, apple pie chunks, butterscotch, caramel, and whipped cream. A lactose-free soft serve ice cream is also available at Pop’s.
Casa Rosada Artisan Gelato
111 South Payne Street
This family-owned and operated gelato shop brings this great Argentinian dessert to Alexandria. Casa Rosada uses highest quality natural ingredients to create their distinctive flavors (such as Malbec, sweet corn, kumquats, and dulce de leche to name a few). Casa Rosada offers 35 different flavors of gelato and 14 flavors of sorbet (20 flavors on any given day). They also sell dog-safe gelato for your four legged friends and gelato cakes for special occasions.
Ben & Jerry’s
103 South Union Street
You can’t go wrong with getting a scoop of one of Ben & Jerry’s creatively-named ice creams. You can’t miss Ben & Jerry’s, just off of King Street, with the bubbles blowing outside of the ice cream shop. You can catch a whiff of their decadent waffle cones from blocks away! Extra hungry? Round up some friends to share a Vermonster sundae, with its 20 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, banana, cookies, brownies, and all of your favorite toppings.
1012 King Street
Killer ESP has had the whole town talking! Offering “all the flavors of Old Town Alexandria in a cup, cone, or crust,” Killer ESP focuses solely on espresso, sorbets, and pies. Enjoy one of its traditional or experimental sorbet flavors. If you aren’t in the mood for sorbet, grab a cup of Stumptown Coffee from Oregon (rumor has it that the Nutella latte is absolutely delicious) or slice of its heavenly pie.
Old Town Dolci Gelati Café
107 North Fairfax Street
Dolci Gelati Chef Gianluigi Dellaccio uses an authentic Italian recipe that has been in his family for generations, but with a modern twist. The flavor options are amazing – bacon gelato, Bellini sorbetti, and their award-winning Saffron Pistachio Candied Lemon Peel to name a few. Chef Dellaccio uses ingredients from local dairy farms and imported Ecuadorian chocolate. Dolci Gelati also makes butterbeer if you can’t make it to Hogwarts. If you can’t make it to the shop, look for Dolci Gelati products in Whole Foods Markets.
212 King Street
Doubling as an ice cream and candy shop, Kilwins has something for anyone with a sweet tooth! Kilwins’ ice cream is made onsite from original recipes along with its chocolates, fudge, apples, corns, and brittles. Enjoy its wide variety of flavors including all of the classics, plus twists like Cinnamon Crumb Cake, Blueberry Waffle Cone, and Pumpkin Pie.
ELSEWHERE IN ALEXANDRIA
The Dairy Godmother
2310 Mount Vernon Avenue
Del Ray’s Dairy Godmother is a local favorite known for its Wisconsin-style custard. The custard is made with very little air the during the process, giving it its dense and creamy texture. Dairy Godmother offers a frozen custard flavor of the day, along with vanilla, chocolate, and sorbet. Be sure to bring your dog for one of its pumpkin or banana “Puppy Pops” or a “Squirrel,” its baked dog treat.
Custard Shack at Del Ray Pizzeria (Belle Haven location)
1401 Belle Haven Road
Did we miss your favorite spot for ice cream in Alexandria? If so, please let us know!
There is more than just great ice cream in Alexandria! For more insight into living in Alexandria, check out our other Inside Alexandria posts and sign up for one of our neighborhood orientation tours today.
For more articles like this one, be sure you’re getting our weekly blog roundup every Monday morning.